We had been having this conversation for days. WordPress v. Tumblr – which blogging platform should we use? We finally decided to go with WordPress but it wasn’t as easy as some would expect. I know there are a lot of friends of mine who blog and keep journals so I figured some of our reasoning might help future bloggers decide. Here is a short write-up of the pros, cons, and why.
WordPress.com –
This is the default to go with when it comes to blogging. Every option one could need to get up and rolling is provided free of charge. You can’t ask for much more as far as features go. A great piece of software and a proper community at anyone’s disposal. Some pros:
- Free to use. (No upfront costs for hosting)
- Managed, no need to update or install plugins.
- Easy to use backend with power user features.
- Plays nice with social networks.
- Large community that helps spread your work out.
- Everything built-in is excellent. Stats, polls, rankings, tools, etc.
For all of those great items there are some short comings. Most of it comes down to specific paid features. Some of these features are readily available on other blogging platforms for free. Some of the cons for WordPress are:
- $12 per year to map your own domain to your blog.
- $15 per year to edit the CSS in any way. (This seems excessive.)
- Community is vast but it seems less social than Tumblr.
- Overly complex for someone just trying to blog random stuff.
- Limited space. 3gb per account.
While some will disagree with the community comment I maintain it to be true. Tumblr really does have an amazing community which I will touch upon momentarily. WordPress has a great community as well but it doesn’t seem to be as organized at least in the way Tumblr’s is. The Tumblr dashboard does a lot of good, also a lot of bad.
Tumblr –
So Tumblr, Tumblr is great. The hype in blogging at the moment and I understand why. It is basic, simple, and easy to get into and see growth. There are several great features and most of the WordPress cons are addressed by Tumblr. Some of the pros are:
- Free.
- Hundreds of free themes that look excellent.
- Ability to post anything with ease.
- Highly customizable.
- Free features like domain mapping for your .com, etc.
- Active and vast community.*
Note that the last one is starred, I’m getting to that. Tumblr’s flaw is the community as much as it is the strength. Tumblr users can “like” or “reblog” a user’s post. This does help share it across the network but it also hurts the post. Often times names and original content are stripped, especially if it is an image.
While the community can interact it is also highly annoying that you can’t interact beyond the original post! Tumblr has no built-in comment system. It does, but not traditional. People can leave comments in the form of a reply but you can’t answer back. This is so counter intuitive it drives me insane. Users need to use third-party comment systems like disqus. Unfortunately this takes away from participation for many people who aren’t familiar with it. How hard is it to just build in working comments!?
Finally the SEO, it is horrible. I have had Tumblr for years now and none of my posts are even remotely searchable in Google. To counter that, posts I’ve submitted on here are already receiving Google traffic. It’s amazing how important that is.
Tumblr is great for casual blogging and for kids and adults who want to share fun stuff with their friends and their community on Tumblr but that is the extent. It is like a walled garden. Great user experience within the walls, no love outside the walls. Either place is a great way to go about sharing your content but ultimately WordPress wins out. It is always the 10,000 lb gorilla in the blogging world and for good reason.
Tumblr is an excellent personal sharing system for things that can be found in a junk drawer. Tumblr is a better Twitter and for that I love it but if I want to crank out a post like this it isn’t even an option right now. Maybe with their new round of funding they can change that? It will be interesting to see.